ELDORA — Traci Lynn Tyler, convicted this month of lesser charges in a child confinement case in Hardin County, on Friday was sentenced to up to a year in jail and fined $315.
Because she had already served around 266 days in county jail prior to April 10, when she was released prior to sentencing, Tyler may only serve about three months more in jail — and that may be cut down even further for good behavior.
Tyler, who elected not to speak in her defense or during sentencing, was taken into custody by the Hardin County Sheriff’s Office directly after the sentencing.
Though he convicted her on a much lesser charge, Ellefson nonetheless told Tyler during her sentencing her offense was “egregious and outrageous,” went beyond the bounds of normal punishment and that she seemed to show no remorse.
“I don’t know if it’s lack of remorse, or if, Ms. Tyler, that you just don’t get it,” Ellefson said Friday. “There was never any realization that what you had done to this child was wrong.”
Thanks for being a regular reader! Here's a special offer for you:
Prosecutors said Tyler and her fiancé, 30-year-old Alex Shadlow, had withheld food from his 8-year-old son, made him sleep in the locked basement enclosure with a coffee can for a toilet in August and September 2017, denied him bathroom breaks and struck him with a wooden spoon and flyswatter.
Tyler’s defense attorneys said the family had sought counseling for behavior issues and argued parents had the right to use corporal punishment.
Ellefson ruled April 10 that Tyler went beyond acceptable punishment.
“This court finds as a fact that the defendant’s actions constitute confinement, and that they went outside of the bounds of reason and moderation for the best interests of the child,” he wrote in his opinion.
“The confinement substantially increased the risk to (the child). He would have been unable to escape any fire or other calamity, and it would have been substantially more difficult for anyone else to rescue him from a fire or other calamity. There was a substantial increase in risk in that if (he) had become ill while in the enclosure he would not have been able to seek assistance,” the judge wrote.
But Ellefson said the evidence didn’t show other elements to establish the kidnapping offense.
The judge found that, despite testimony Tyler struck the child with a flyswatter and wooden spoon, there was no intent to cause serious injury. The judge also said there was no evidence of malnutrition as the child had a normal body mass index.
The judge said it was more likely the child was holding in his urine by his own choice, and he noted the boy told a mental health counselor he was urinating and defecating in places other than the toilet because he didn’t like living with Tyler and her rules.
Tyler’s fiancé, 30-year-old Alex Shadlow, is awaiting trial.
Alex Shadlow and Traci Tyler
Traci Lynn Tyler
Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter
Get the latest in local public safety news with this weekly email
Staff writer at The Courier 2005 (college intern), 2007-2012, 2015-present. Graduate of UNI 2006. Three-time Iowa APME award winner (investigative reporting 2008, lifestyle feature 2016, business feature 2018)