Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

REVIEW: 'She Said' meticulously details the Weinstein case

  • 0

Movie critic Bruce Miller says “She Said” is a strong statement about journalism but it’s an even stronger look at the movie industry and the silence that fuels it.

The process of newsgathering is almost too detailed in “She Said.”

Some of the reporting moments seem crafted, not spontaneous. And when the two reporters finally get to ask questions, those questions sound like they were carefully vetted by an attorney before they were uttered.

Part of that could be the case – movie titan Harvey Weinstein is still in the news, still on trial, facing charges of criminal sexual assault and rape.

Part of it also could be a matter of staying focused. Too much attention to the reporters (played by Carey Mulligan and Zoe Kazan) could shift the story and make this like “Spotlight” or “The Paper.”

Interestingly, there are moments that seem lifted from “All the President’s Men.” “She Said” differs in its technology. Woodward and Bernstein pounded on typewriters; Mulligan’s Megan Twohey and Kazan’s Jodi Kantor use laptops and cellphones. Much, in fact, is carried out on phones, which must have been a challenge for director Maria Schrader. Even the New York Times’ new building seems flat.

But when the two begin their work, interviews pop to life. Jennifer Ehle, in particular, is incredible as a woman detailing her experience with Weinstein and the impression it left.

Listen now and subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | RSS Feed | Omny Studio

One by one, these gems of acting slip in, until the newspaper’s editors have to decide if they’re going to go ahead with the story or fold. When they get Weinstein on the phone, Andre Braugher is particularly good as the editor who isn’t going to play games. Patricia Clarkson is winning, too, as the editor who guides the reporters through a mass of information and sources.

While the real Ashley Judd is here, other actresses are either shot from a distance or dealt with through phone calls.

Interestingly, “She Said” begins with women alleging that Donald Trump assaulted them. That story didn’t seem like such a hand wringer, but the Weinstein one does.

When he confronts management (not unlike John Mitchell in “All the President’s Men”), Weinstein is allowed time to respond. There’s mention of Ronan Farrow’s similar story but “She Said” doesn’t detail where his lands next to the one from the Times.

Mulligan and Kazan get their emotional moments at home (both are mothers, both wrestle with the work/family balance) but are deadly serious at work – almost too serious. The film never covers the down moments or show reporters doing anything but interviewing. (How they can get work done in those small cubicles is anyone’s guess.) When editors gather around a computer, ready to publish on the web, you can sense the anticipation.

While it talks about a bigger problem in Hollywood, “She Said” is very focused on Weinstein. It alludes to the intimidation that hangs over other professions and shows how valuable one person speaking out can be.

“She Said” stays on course. A sequel could reveal just how Weinstein’s ways have been a way of life in Hollywood.



* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News