Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

Ethanol bounces back after tough year

  • 0

STEAMBOAT ROCK --- Cheaper corn, rising oil prices and smarter business decisions are powering ethanol's road to recovery.

Nearly a year ago, the renewable fuels industry was sputtering. The state's largest ethanol producer at the time, VeraSun Energy Corp., filed for bankruptcy last Halloween and one of the smallest farmer-owned plants, Pine Lake Corn Processors, near Steamboat Rock, followed suit two months later.

Several ethanol plants nationwide were shuttered, construction ground to a halt on others and those that did survive weren't making money. A combination of record-high corn and low ethanol prices crippled the industry.

Corn soared to nearly $8 per bushel during the summer of 2008, and wholesale ethanol plunged to about $1.50 per gallon. The companies that got into serious financial trouble bought too much high-priced corn and didn't sell enough ethanol when it was $3 per gallon to cover expenses.

"We were not able to hedge ethanol along with purchasing corn," said Larry Meints, president of Pine Lake Corn Processors. "We weren't alone."

Today, the economics fueling ethanol's engine is making it purr once again. Local ethanol plants are purchasing corn for a little more than $3.80 per bushel and ethanol is worth almost $2 per gallon.

Plant officials say they're not making money hand over fist, but ethanol is profitable again.

"It's looking better," Meints said. "This is the best crush margins have been in a while."

A bankruptcy court ruling is scheduled for Nov. 18 concerning Pine Lake's reorganization plan. If approved, the plant will emerge from Chapter 11 with Prairie Land Cooperative of Hubbard, its largest creditor, as majority owner.

Officials say the ethanol business has stabilized. That's good news for farmers supplying its chief ingredient, thousands of Iowans employed by the industry and the state's economy.

A study released earlier this year by the Iowa Renewable Fuels Association said ethanol and biodiesel refineries add nearly $12 billion, or about 9 percent, to Iowa's gross domestic product.

"In addition to the rather large current impact, increased demand for renewable fuels would provide a serious boost to Iowa's economy," IRFA Executive Director Monte Shaw said in a prepared statement.

San Antonio-based Valero Energy Corp. says it is bullish about ethanol. North America's largest oil refiner purchased seven former VeraSun plants, including one near Charles City, and one development site from the defunct company.

Valero spokesman Bill Day said all the plants are profitable and, if the right opportunity came along, the company might buy more. It spent $477 million on the initial deal because it blended the corn-based fuel and wanted a dedicated supply, Day had said previously.

"We are very pleased with the purchase," Day said. "Market conditions have changed to our advantage. And the (record) harvest in Iowa signals good things for the industry."

Processors say several factors are working in their favor now. Crude oil prices are on the rise --- a barrel that cost little more than $30 at the end of 2008 was worth more than $82 Oct. 22 --- and ethanol usually follows. Corn prices are lower than last year and fairly stable. Compared to the price of oil, ethanol is cheap enough that refiners are blending ethanol, even if they aren't required to do so.

Most importantly, processors say they have learned from past mistakes. Gone are the days of extended corn contracts without a guarantee of income to cover expenses.

"We have a different system for corn contracts and expertise in commodity trading," Day said.

Apparently, the public still supports ethanol despite the industry's financial difficulties last year. A survey released earlier this month by the University of Wisconsin-Madison determined more than 60 percent of people use and support the production of ethanol. However, only 48 percent believe tax dollars should subsidize it.

Professor Dietram Scheufele says the answers from the 600 people questioned in the Badger state are typical of others in the Midwest.

"(The government) is emphasizing green jobs and renewable energy," Scheufele said. "We're seeing the whole thing coming back."


* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News