MANHATTAN, Kan. — In true Iowa State versus Kansas State fashion, Saturday’s game went down to the wire and the Wildcats won for the ninth straight time in the most recent Bill Snyder era, 20-19.
Iowa State led 19-14 and the Cyclones were driving in the fourth quarter with under five minutes left in the Big 12 Conference matchup.
Iowa State quarterback Kyle Kempt scrambled on second down and as he was sliding, he was tackled. The referees threw a flag for a late hit.
Then they picked it up.
“They didn’t think it was forceful contact,” Kempt said. “That’s their call.”
Did Kempt, the person who got hit, think it felt forceful?
“It did,” Kempt said.
Iowa State got the third-down conversion, and it appeared the Cyclones were going to try and run out the clock and force Kansas State to burn its timeouts.
ISU gained four yards on a first down run, then threw an incomplete pass on second down. On third down, the Cyclones tried to keep the drive alive with another pass.
Kempt threw a back-shoulder pass to Allen Lazard — one of the Cyclones’ most reliable plays. Lazard went up for it and there was contact. The referees threw the flag, but then they huddled together to talk about the penalty.
“I look over at the refs and they’re looking up at the scoreboard and reviewing the play and what not and I’m pretty sure they’re not supposed to do that to decide an outcome on that call,” Lazard said.
The referees picked up the flag. So instead of first down on the 34 with 2:00 left and Kansas State with two timeouts, Iowa State had to punt.
“I said this after the Oklahoma State game, officiating is hard,” Campbell said. “It’s a tough business, it’s a tough profession and those calls probably could’ve gone either which way. It’s unfortunate because I thought the last one at least certainly looked (like pass interference).”
The lead official in the game, Reggie Smith said it’s Big 12 policy to not discuss judgment calls.
Kansas State got the ball, marched down the field and scored the game-winning touchdown with no time remaining.
But even that drive wasn’t without controversy. Campbell said he saw a false start on a Kansas State guard.
“Probably my biggest issue is there is a false start on the second-to-last play of the game and they don’t call it,” Campbell said. “And I think that’s your issue sometimes with inconsistencies.”
In total, the referees picked up three flags, all in the fourth quarter, all in key situations and two of them on the final drive. The first flag they picked up was an offensive pass interference against Kansas State on the Wildcats’ second touchdown drive of the game.
Iowa State left with a familiar feeling. Two years ago in Manhattan, the Cyclones had the game won, but a fumble late in the fourth quarter allowed Kansas State to come back and win.
“Same exact situation almost,” linebacker Joel Lanning said. “Definitely a heartbreaker. It sucks. I’ve never been down here and had a good experience. It’s definitely a terrible way to end your regular season.”
Lazard did note one difference.
“We felt like we had the game won and it was just taken from us and it wasn’t necessarily anything we did,” Lazard said. “The flag getting taken away from us.
“Obviously, that would’ve gone to first down, they had two timeouts left and we more than likely would’ve ran out the clock but obviously in the game of football, you never know what could’ve happened. Something like what happened in 2015 could’ve happened again if we did get that call.”
It’s not like Iowa State didn’t make mistakes. The Cyclones have plenty to correct. They were in the red zone twice in the first half and only came away with field goals.
“We’re going to learn from the film, correct our mistakes and just move on from it,” Lazard said. “Hopefully the guys next year store this in the back of their mind.”
Kansas St. 20, Iowa St. 19
Iowa St. 3 3 6 7 — 19
Kansas St. 0 7 0 13 — 20
ISU—FG Ga. Owens 36, 7:52. (Drive: 15 plays, 56 yards, 7:08).
KS—Thompson 3 run (McCrane kick), 12:54. (Drive: 8 plays, 31 yards, 5:11).
ISU—FG Ga. Owens 22, 1:33. (Drive: 9 plays, 55 yards, 2:22).
ISU—Murdock 9 pass from Kempt (pass failed), 8:34. (Drive: 11 plays, 85 yards, 4:57).
ISU—Butler 3 pass from Kempt (Ga.Owens kick), 13:46. (Drive: 10 plays, 62 yards, 6:12).
KS—Dimel 3 pass from Barnes (McCrane kick), 6:07. (Drive: 13 plays, 68 yards, 7:28).
KS—Zuber 1 pass from Thompson (run failed), :00. (Drive: 10 plays, 87 yards, 1:55).
First downs 18 12
Rushes-yards 30-115 30-109
Passing yards 264 155
Comp-att-int 24-36-0 16-22-0
Return yards -9 127
Punts-avg. 4-26.5 4-50.5
Fumbles-lost 0-0 0-0
Penalties-yards 9-85 4-45
Time of possession 33:32 26:28
IOWA STATE — Croney 13-63, Warren 4-17, Montgomery 4-14, Kempt 7-11, Lanning 1-9, Ryen 1-1.
KANSAS STATE — Warmack 10-42, Silmon 5-32, Barnes 7-23, Thompson 8-12.
IOWA STATE — Kempt 24-36-0, 264 yards.
KANSAS STATE — Barnes 1-1-0, 3 yards, Thompson 15-21-0, 152 yards.
IOWA STATE — Lazard 6-95, Ryen 5-36, Murdock 4-37, Croney 3-15, D. Jones 2-43, Butler 2-23, Eaton 1-9, Montgomery 1-6.
KANSAS STATE — Zuber 7-56, Heath 3-23, Reuter 2-38, Dimel 2-7, Warmack 1-24, Barnes 1-7.
IOWA STATE — Lanning 5-2-7, Peavy 5-1-6, Harvey 5-0-5, Edwards 4-0-4, Cotton-Moya 3-1-4, Spears 3-0-3, Waggoner 2-1-3, Wilkerson 2-1-3, Bailey 2-0-2, Epps 2-0-2, Lima 2-0-2, Trent 1-0-1, Grant 1-0-1, Alexander 1-0-1, Payne 1-0-1, Uwazurike 1-0-1.
KANSAS STATE — Kirby 7-1-8, Goolsby 6-2-8, Walker 5-1-6, Tanking 4-2-6, Geary 4-0-4, Moore 4-0-4, Shelley 3-0-3, Wood 2-1-3, Durham 2-0-2, Massie 1-1-2, Dishon 1-1-2, Sullivan 1-0-1, Davies 1-0-1, Zuber 1-0-1, Burns 1-0-1, Ball 1-0-1.
Tackles for loss
IOWA STATE — Lanning 2-3, Spears 1-1.
KANSAS STATE — Kirby 1-8, Davis 1-6.
IOWA STATE — Lanning 1-2.
KANSAS STATE — Kirby 1-8, Davis 1-6.